A recent Michigan Court of Appeals opinion has caught the attention of lenders and developers alike. In Wells Fargo Bank NA v. Cherryland Mall Limited, ___ Mich App___ Case No. 304682 (April 9, 2013), the Court on remand from the Michigan Supreme Court, rejected the constitutionality challenges to Michigan's NonRecourse Mortgage Loan Act (NMLA) and barred the plaintiff’s claims. The holding had the effect of prohibiting Wells Fargo from collecting $2.1 Million pursuant to a Guaranty by developer David Schostak, and likely has the same impact for other nonrecourse commercial mortgage-backed securities.
The facts of the case arise out of a nonrecourse loan that was secured by a mortgage in Cherryland Mall, and guaranteed by its developer. When a default in the loan occurred due to a post closing solvency covenant, the lender foreclosed and then attempted to pursue the deficiency pursuant to the guaranty. While the case was pending, the Michigan legislature passed the NMLA, and made it applicable to “the enforcement and interpretation of all nonrecourse loan documents in existence on, or entered into on or after the effective date of [the NMLA].”
The court construed and applied the new law which protects developers statewide. The Defendants successfully argued that the NMLA invalidated the guaranty because it was based on the post-closing solvency covenant carved out as a basis of the claim. Wells Fargo argued the NMLA was unconstitutional because it applied retroactively and invalidated the Guaranty. The Court of Appeals disagreed, and found the NMLA constitutional because there was a significant and public purpose for the NMLA. The Court agreed that the NMLA was enacted to avert a broader economic problem that was in the interest of the public good and to stabilize the commercial mortgage backed securities industry.
The case discussed and confirmed the constitutionality of the NMLA. Its impact will likely have reach on other non-recourse loans and single purpose loans statewide, and throughout the CMBS industry, by protecting developers in such cases.
The business and employment attorneys of Dalton & Tomich take your business just as seriously as you do. Attorneys Zana Tomich and Noel Sterett are trusted by closely held family businesses and others across Michigan and Northern Illinois as invaluable partners and counselors. We guarantee all your calls and emails will be returned within one business day so you can focus on what you do best: running your business.
Having worked with Zana for 10 years, I can attest to her professionalism, her pragmatism, and most importantly, her integrity. I always get sound, thoughtful advice and guidance. From routine filings & updates to the highly unexpected, Zana’s there to help, always responding quickly and […]Read More
We highly recommend Dalton & Tomich! As a start-up firm that has rapidly grown across the country in under 5 years, Dalton & Tomich has been integral to our sound, credible, and excellent in standard infrastructure. As we’ve scaled, Zana has been right by our […]Read More
As a professional photographer in the wedding industry, reliable communication is very important to me. Noel was very knowledgeable and quick to respond to all of my questions and not just that, he also gave me suggestions when reviewing and updating my contract. The entire […]Read More
Zana’s expert guidance has helped us to move forward with clarity and confidence in our business endeavors. She helped us create a new business entity, and a few years later to navigate a tricky buyout—all with a clear path forward for business growth. Her calm […]Read More
Noel’s guidance was much appreciated when redrafting my client contract. He was very professional, respectful of my time and potential costs, and was sincere with his advice. I trusted that he had the highest good for my business in mind. I will seek out his […]Read More
Zana’s expertise in employee law has helped us refine and build a stronger operations and hiring strategy at my company. As a business owner of a small and fast growing company, I very much appreciate Zana’s ability to always step into any situation quickly and […]Read More